Is It Easy To Replace A Toilet?

Imagine you're a handy homeowner, ready to roll up your sleeves and tackle any home improvement project.

One day, you notice that your toilet is constantly running, leaking, or just past its prime, and it's time for an upgrade. The question arises: Is it easy to replace a toilet?

In a broad sense, it is not easy to replace a toilet wthout being an expert. Plumbing can be an intimidatng task reserved only for professionals and replcaning a toilet is more complex than it may appear.

The process involves shutting off the water, draining the tank, disconnecting supply lines, removing the old toilet, and installing a new one with a fresh wax ring. 

This means if youre not careful, complications can arise, like corroded bolts or uneven floors, which may require professional assistance.

Whether you're considering replacing a toilet due to necessity or simply because you want to give your bathroom a fresh look, we have the practical advice and professional guidance.

So let's dive right in!

Can You Just Replace a Toilet?

Absolutely, you can replace your toilet yourself, but seeking help from a professional remodeler or plumber would be the best approach. They possess the necessary knowledge and expertise to install a toilet, which can help you minimize costs and avoid potential mistakes during a DIY toilet installation.

The first step is to consider the type of toilet you want as a replacement. Various options are available, ranging from traditional two-piece models to modern one piece designs with integrated bidets and other advanced features. 

Before starting the project, it's essential to determine the cost estimation to avoid any surprises regarding the bill. Having a clear financial plan will help you stay on track.

In essence, toilet replacement is a feasible task if you approach it thoughtfully, but involving a professional plumber or bathroom remodel experts will ensure a smoother and more efficient installation process. Their expertise and knowledge will help you achieve the desired results while minimizing potential issues and costs.

Toilet for guest bathrooms

What are the Reasons to Replace a Toilet?

While your old porcelain toilet may hold sentimental value, there are several reasons to replace it.

  • Outdated Design: If your current toilet has an old-fashioned style with faded colors or scratches, it can detract from the overall appeal of your space.
  • Constant Repairs: Frequent repairs to your toilet may indicate that it's reaching the end of its lifespan and needs replacement. Investing in a new toilet can save you from the costs on ongoing adjustments.
  • Plumbing Issues: If you experience frequent clogs or leaks, it could be a sign that your current toilet is malfunctioning. Replacing it with a modern system can improve plumbing conditions in your home.
  • Cost Savings: While the upfront cost of a new toilet may seem significant, the long-term savings from reduced water usage and fewer repairs can make it a financially sensible choice.
  • Eco-Friendliness: Newer toilets often incorporate advanced technologies like dual-flush options, which contribute positively to environmental conservation efforts by using less water when appropriate.
  • Improved Aesthetics: A new toilet with a modern design can enhance the overall look and feel of your bathroom, creating a more pleasant and updated space.
  • Enhanced Efficiency: Upgrading to a newer toilet model can increase water usage and flushing performance efficiency, providing a more reliable and effective flushing experience.
  • Better Hygiene: Some older toilets may have worn-out components that can compromise hygiene. Replacing your toilet ensures a clean and sanitary bathroom environment.

Upgrading to a newer toilet model can significantly affect cost savings and eco-friendliness. So while it might be tempting to hang onto that vintage throne out of nostalgia or fear of change, remember that investing in a new toilet replacement can lead to increased efficiency, improved aesthetics, and better plumbing conditions within your home.

Toilet beside the bathtub shower

How Long Does It Take to Replace a New Toilet?

Don't worry; you won't be left without your bathroom throne for too long; a professional can typically install a new toilet in just two to four hours, giving you the comfort and efficiency you deserve in no time at all. This period includes the time it takes to remove the toilet, prepare the area for the new toilet, and complete the installation process.

The duration can vary based on factors such as toilet dimensions and whether unexpected challenges arise during replacement. For instance, if your new toilet has different dimensions than your old toilet or there are issues with your plumbing system that need addressing before replacement can proceed.

Toilet replacement is not overly complex, it requires specific installation tools like a wrench and plunger. You'll also need to consider budget planning, as costs might vary depending on whether you're going for flushing efficiency or water conservation features in your new unit.


  • Flushing Efficiency: Toilets with high-efficiency flush systems will cost more upfront but save you money over time by reducing water usage. These toilets are ideal for those who wish to serve their community by conserving water.
  • Water Conservation: Opting for a dual-flush toilet allows users to choose between different flush volumes, further enhancing water conservation. This feature is perfect for people looking out for their needs and caring about our planet's well-being.
How Long Does It Take To Replace A New Toilet

Can You Replace the Toilet Without Replacing the Floor?

Imagine this: you're considering upgrading your throne but concerned about the state of your floor—well, fret not because it's possible to install a new water closet without tearing up and redoing the entire flooring.

While there might be some installation difficulties, you can prevent floor damage during toilet replacement with the right approach and necessary tools. One key tool is a wax ring which helps seal the connection between the toilet base and the sewer pipe, preventing potential leaks that could cause significant harm to your floor.

Before you replace your old toilet, inspecting for underlying plumbing issues that may compromise your new toilet replacement down the line is crucial. Observe any signs of toilet base leaking as this could indicate more severe complications like rotted subflooring or broken flange, requiring attention before new toilet placement.

Toilet room floor style

What's the Best Way to Replace a Toilet?

When replacing a toilet, you might be torn between doing it yourself and hiring a professional. Both options have their own merits. DIY can save you money if you're comfortable with the job, but hiring a professional ensures that the job is done first and saves you from potential mishaps.

There are several factors to consider when hiring a professional. Consider their credentials, experience, and cost of services to ensure optimal results.

Two-piece toilet for kids

DIY vs Hiring a Professional

You might be contemplating whether to tackle toilet replacement as a DIY project or hire a professional, and weighing the pros and cons of each option is important. On the one hand, doing it yourself could save you some money on labor costs, but it also comes with challenges. 

Some of those challenges include having the necessary tools for the job, understanding how to properly remove the old toilet and install the new one without causing any damage or leaks, and finding time in your schedule to complete this job.

Here's a quick comparison table to help illustrate these points:




Only materials needed; potential savings on labor

Costs can include consultation fees, labor charges, and possibly material markups


Can take longer due to the learning curve; must find free time in your schedule

Professionals have an experience that allows them to work faster; no need for you to allocate personal time

Skill & Tools Required

Requires basic plumbing skills; must have or acquire necessary tools

Professionals are skilled and equipped with all necessary tools

Toilet and glass walk in shower

Considerations When Hiring a Professional

Having weighed the pros and cons of DIY and hiring a professional, you might be leaning towards the other. That's perfectly fine. After all, engaging a professional can save you time and the headaches that come with potential mistakes.

Before you pick up your phone to call the first plumber on your contact list, certain factors should guide your decision.

  1. Check qualifications and expertise (proper certifications and knowledge of bathroom plumbing).

  2. Request a detailed upfront quote for cost estimation.

  3. Inquire about warranty and guarantees for their workmanship.

 Remember, serving others not only means doing good but also making informed decisions when seeking help themselves.

White two-piece toilet beside bathtub

How Often Should a Toilet Be Replaced?

Ironically, it's not your decision when to replace the toilet; the toilet decides for you. The lifespan of a toilet can vary greatly depending on its use and maintenance frequency.

Generally, a well-maintained toilet can last between 20-50 years. But, frequent issues such as constant clogs, cracks, or leaks might indicate that your throne needs replacing sooner rather than later.

Here are some factors to consider:

  • Toilet Lifespan: Remember that while toilets can last several decades with proper care, they're not meant to be permanent fixtures. Regular check-ups and maintenance will extend their life expectancy.

  • Maintenance Frequency: A neglected toilet will likely need early replacement. Regular cleaning and upkeep go a long way in ensuring your unit lasts as long as possible.

  • Replacement Costs: Replacing a toilet isn't just about buying a new one; there could also be costs associated with removing the old one and installing the new model.

  • Environmental Impact: Older models consume more water per flush, negatively affecting our environment. When considering replacement, look into high-efficiency models designed for water conservation.

  • High-Efficiency Models: They may have higher upfront costs but pay off in the long run by reducing water usage and utility bills.

How Often Should A Toilet Be Replaced

To Sum Up

Don't let your bathroom become a source of stress; instead, transform it into a sanctuary of efficiency and elegance. From the humble porcelain throne to your plumbing system, Phoenix Home Remodeling is here to help you make informed decisions, saving you time and budget in the long run.

Consult with Phoenix Home Remodeling today and let us steer you towards an efficient, cost-effective, and eco-friendly bathroom upgrade. Remember, a well-planned remodeling project not only improves your quality of life but also increases the value of your home.

Toilet Room with shower and bathtub

FAQs: Is It Easy To Replace A Toilet

What tools are necessary for replacing a toilet?

Juxtapose Toilet Measurements and Flange Fixing; it's a dance of precision. Essentials include a wrench for wax ring installation, a level for toilet leveling, and a screwdriver for tank placement. You're equipped to serve in bathroom emergencies!

Do I need a plumber to replace the toilet, or can I do it myself?

While you can tackle toilet replacement yourself, consider DIY challenges like ensuring correct toilet dimensions. Disposal methods, time commitment, and safety precautions are also factors. If unsure, hiring a plumber might be best for you.

How much does it cost to replace the toilet?

Did you know toilet replacement costs range from $200 to $750? This includes the installation timeline, plumbing, disposal methods, and electrical if needed. 

Are there different types of toilets to consider when replacing?

Absolutely, when replacing a toilet, consider aesthetics, space limitations, water-saving options, comfort preferences, and longevity. Aesthetics depend on your style, compact designs suit small spaces, high-efficiency toilets save water, and elongated models boost comfort.

What are the environmental implications of replacing a toilet?

Toilet replacement has significant environmental implications. Consider eco-friendly options that offer water conservation benefits, reducing your carbon footprint. Also, understand waste disposal implications and explore toilet recycling possibilities for a greener choice.

PDF version:

Video of this post:

Podcast about How simple is it to replace the toilet:

Do you live in Ahwatukee, Chandler, Gilbert, Mesa, Tempe,  Sun Lakes, Laveen, or South Phoenix?

Ready to talk about your remodeling needs?

Take the next step...

About the author

Hi my name is Jeremy Maher. My wife, 2 kids and I went through Contractor Nightmares for 3 years straight.

Ben, Mark, and I teamed up to start Phoenix Home Remodeling to help homeowners remodel without the common contractor nightmares.

Learn more about Jeremy's expertise and topics he likes to write about on his author page.