Pros And Cons of Shower Tile: Making the right choice

When considering a bathroom renovation or a new build through a shower remodel contractor, the choice of shower tile is pivotal making the need for knowing the pros and cons of shower tile important. 

Shower tiles offer durability, design variety, and water resistance, enhancing aesthetics and home value. However, they come with higher initial costs, and require maintenance, especially for grout, which can harbor mold if not properly cared for.

Deciding whether or not to purchase shower tiles can be challenging, but this guide is meant to make that choice easier.

Importance of Choosing the Right Tile

Selecting the right tile for your shower is a critical decision that affects not only the appearance of your bathroom but also its functionality and durability over time. 

The importance of this choice cannot be overstated, as it influences maintenance requirements, safety, overall bathroom aesthetics, and even the value of your home.

Pros And Cons Of Shower Tile1

Pros of Shower Tile

Choosing the right tile for your shower is not just about aesthetics; it's a decision that impacts your bathroom's longevity, maintenance, and overall functionality. 

Shower tiles offer many advantages that cater to diverse needs and preferences, making them a popular choice for bathroom renovations and new builds. 

Here's a closer look at the significant pros of opting for shower tile.

Durability and Longevity

One of the most compelling benefits of shower tiles is their durability. Tiles made from materials like porcelain or ceramic are incredibly resilient and can withstand the daily wear and tear of bathroom activities. 

Tiles maintain their integrity and appearance for years, unlike other shower surfaces that might crack, chip, or fade over time. This makes them a cost-effective solution in the long run, as they rarely need to be replaced due to wear.

Variety in Design and Aesthetics

Shower tiles offer unparalleled versatility in design. Whether you envision a sleek, modern look or a cozy, traditional ambiance, there's a tile to fit every vision. 

The vast array of colors, patterns, and textures available allows for personalized design schemes that can complement any bathroom style. 

Additionally, the ability to mix and match tile sizes and shapes opens up endless possibilities for creative and unique layouts.

Water and Moisture Resistance

A critical advantage of shower tiles is their inherent resistance to water and moisture. Bathrooms are high-humidity environments, and materials that can withstand constant exposure to water without deteriorating are essential. 

Properly installed and sealed tiles offer an impermeable barrier, protecting walls and subfloors from water damage. This resistance also helps prevent mold and mildew growth, contributing to a healthier bathroom environment.

Easy Maintenance and Cleaning

Compared to other shower surface materials, tiles are relatively easy to maintain. Routine cleaning with simple soap and water can keep tiles looking new for years. Tiles are also resistant to stains, odors, and chemicals, making them an ideal choice for those looking for a low-maintenance bathroom solution. 

Even when deeper cleaning is necessary, such as with grout, the process is straightforward and can significantly extend the life and appearance of your shower.

Eco-Friendly Options

For environmentally conscious homeowners, many tile options are made from natural, sustainable materials. Ceramic and porcelain tiles, for instance, are often made from clay, a plentiful resource, and can be recycled. 

Additionally, the long lifespan of tiles reduces the need for frequent replacements, minimizing waste.

Adds Value to Your Home

Installing high-quality tiles in your shower can also increase the overall value of your home. Bathrooms are a key selling point in real estate, and a beautifully tiled shower can be a significant attraction for potential buyers. 

The aesthetic appeal and practical benefits of shower tiles make them a worthwhile investment in your property.

Pros And Cons Of Shower Tile2

Cons of Shower Tile

While shower tiles offer numerous benefits, it's important to consider the potential drawbacks before deciding. 

Understanding the pros and cons of shower tiles can help homeowners weigh their options and make an informed choice that meets their needs and preferences. 

Here are some of the main cons associated with shower tiles.

Initial Cost and Installation Complexity

One of the significant downsides of choosing shower tiles is the initial cost, especially if you opt for high-end materials like natural stone. The price of the tiles themselves, along with the cost of additional materials (such as grout and sealant) and labor for professional installation, can make tiling your shower a considerable investment. 

Additionally, the installation process is more complex and time-consuming than some other shower surfaces, requiring precise measurements, cuts, and laying techniques. 

This complexity often necessitates hiring a professional, further increasing the overall cost.

Slip Hazard and Comfort

Tiles, particularly when wet, can become slippery, posing a safety risk in the shower. Polished tiles or those with a glossy finish can exacerbate this hazard, increasing the likelihood of slips and falls. 

Moreover, tiles can feel cold to the touch, which may be uncomfortable for some individuals, especially in cooler climates or during the winter months. 

This lack of warmth underfoot can detract from the overall comfort of using the shower.

Grout Maintenance and Mold Growth

Although the tiles themselves are durable and easy to clean, the grout between the tiles can present maintenance challenges. Grout is porous and can absorb water and soap residue, leading to staining and the growth of mold and mildew. 

Grout with epoxy dramatically reduces these issues. 

Regardless, all types  require regular cleaning and occasional resealing to maintain a fresh and clean appearance. Neglecting grout maintenance can result in unsightly shower walls and floors and in severe cases, may even compromise the integrity of the tile work.

Limited Repair Options

If a tile cracks or becomes damaged, repair options can be limited. While individual tiles can sometimes be replaced, finding an exact match years after the initial installation can be difficult due to changes in tile batches or the discontinuation of specific lines. 

This can result in a patchwork appearance that detracts from the overall aesthetics of the shower. Additionally, the process of replacing tiles can be labor-intensive and costly, especially if the damage is extensive.

Environmental Impact

While there are eco-friendly tile options, the production of certain types of tiles can have a significant environmental impact. The manufacturing process for porcelain and ceramic tiles, for example, is energy-intensive, contributing to carbon emissions. 

Moreover, the extraction of natural stone can lead to habitat destruction and other environmental concerns. For environmentally conscious homeowners, these factors may be a significant drawback.

Pros And Cons Of Shower Tile3

FAQs on Pros And Cons of Shower Tile

What types of tiles are best for shower walls and floors?

Ceramic and porcelain tiles are popular for their durability, water resistance, and wide range of designs. Natural stone tiles offer a unique look but require more maintenance.

How do I clean shower tiles and grout?

Use a mild detergent and warm water for routine cleaning. For grout, a mixture of baking soda and vinegar applied with a brush can effectively remove mold and mildew.

Can shower tiles be installed over an existing surface?

Yes, tiles can be installed over certain existing surfaces, including old tiles, if the surface is clean, flat, and stable. However, a professional evaluation is recommended to ensure proper adherence and waterproofing.

Are there slip-resistant tiles for shower floors?

Yes, many tiles are designed with slip-resistant surfaces. Look for tiles rated for floor use with a high coefficient of friction (COF) to ensure safety when wet.

How often should grout be sealed in a shower?

Grout sealing should be done at least once a year to maintain water resistance and prevent staining. High-traffic showers or those in high-moisture environments may require more frequent sealing.

Evaluating Shower Tile

Deciding whether shower tile is the right choice for your bathroom comes down to balancing the benefits against the potential drawbacks and considering your specific needs and preferences. 

Shower tiles offer a blend of durability, aesthetic versatility, and water resistance, making them a popular choice for many homeowners. They can elevate the look of your bathroom, enhance its functionality, and potentially increase your home's value. 

Video of this post:

PDF version:

You may also be interested in these topics about Shower tile...

Do you live in Ahwatukee, Chandler, Gilbert, Mesa, Tempe,  Sun Lakes, Laveen, or South Phoenix?

Ready to talk about your remodeling needs?

Take the next step...

About the author

Hi my name is Jeremy Maher. My wife, 2 kids and I went through Contractor Nightmares for 3 years straight.

Ben, Mark, and I teamed up to start Phoenix Home Remodeling to help homeowners remodel without the common contractor nightmares.

Learn more about Jeremy's expertise and topics he likes to write about on his author page.

Skip to content