Thermostatic Valve vs. Pressure-Balance Valve

Shower valves might not be the first thing on your mind when you think about bathroom renovations or upgrades. However, they play a crucial role in ensuring your showering experience is as pleasant and safe as possible. 

Unlike pressure-balance valves, thermostatic valves offer precise temperature control, ideal for consistent, safe shower experiences, while pressure-balance valves maintain stable temperatures by balancing water pressure, providing a cost-effective solution against sudden temperature changes. The choice depends on budget and preference for temperature accuracy vs. cost.

This article by a shower remodel contractor aims to provide a comprehensive comparison of these two options, helping you make an informed decision for your bathroom.

Understanding Valves: A Primer

In any plumbing system, a valve is fundamental. At its core, a valve is a device that regulates, directs, or controls the flow of a fluid (gases, liquids, fluidized solids, or slurries) by opening, closing, or partially obstructing various passageways. 

Valve control is crucial in home plumbing, as it controls the delivery of water and manages its flow rate, direction, and temperature.

When it comes to shower systems, the importance of valves becomes even more pronounced. A well-functioning valve ensures a steady temperature and flow, providing a comfortable and safe showering experience. 

There are primarily two types of valves discussed in residential shower systems: thermostatic valves and pressure-balance valves. Both serve the purpose of maintaining the desired water temperature and protecting against sudden temperature changes that could result in discomfort or burns

Thermostatic Valve vs. Pressure-Balance Valve2

What is a Thermostatic Valve?

A thermostatic valve is a sophisticated device in plumbing systems designed to control the temperature of water output, such as in showers or faucets, to a precise level, regardless of fluctuations in the water supply temperature or pressure. 

This type of valve is essential for ensuring a consistent and comfortable user experience, particularly in environments where water temperature stability is crucial for safety and comfort, like in bathrooms and kitchens.

Key Features

  • Temperature Regulation: The primary feature of a thermostatic valve is its ability to maintain a constant water temperature. Users can set their desired temperature, and the valve will automatically adjust the mix of hot and cold water to maintain this setting.

  • Safety: Thermostatic valves are built with safety in mind. They prevent scalding by immediately compensating for sudden changes in water supply conditions. If cold water supply fails, for instance, the valve will shut off the flow of hot water to prevent burns.

  • Efficiency: By maintaining a steady temperature without the need for manual adjustment, thermostatic valves can contribute to water and energy conservation.

How It Works

The operation of a thermostatic valve centers around a thermal element or thermostat within the valve. This thermostat expands or contracts in response to changes in the temperature of the water flowing through it. 

As it changes, it adjusts a valve that balances the ratio of hot to cold water, ensuring the output temperature remains constant.

  • Setting the Temperature: The user sets the desired temperature for the water output.

  • Detecting Temperature Changes: The thermostatic element in the valve senses changes in the temperature of the incoming water.

  • Adjusting Water Flow: Based on the temperature detected, the valve automatically adjusts the proportions of hot and cold water mixed, ensuring the output water temperature matches the user's set preference.

  • Safety Mechanism: In case of a failure in the cold water supply, the thermostatic element reacts by cutting off the hot water supply, preventing scalding.

Thermostatic Valve vs. Pressure-Balance Valve3

What is a Pressure-Balance Valve?

A pressure-balance valve is a type of plumbing valve that plays a crucial role in maintaining a consistent water temperature in your shower or bathtub, even as the water pressure fluctuates due to other uses of water in your home. 

This valve is designed to protect you from sudden and uncomfortable changes in water temperature, which can happen, for instance, when a toilet is flushed or a washing machine starts, diverting water away and affecting the shower's temperature.

Key Features

  • Pressure Adjustment: The core function of a pressure-balance valve is to detect changes in the pressure of the hot or cold water supply and to balance these changes by adjusting the water flow. This keeps the shower temperature within a safe and comfortable range, minimizing the risk of scalding or thermal shock.

  • Simplicity and Reliability: These valves are known for their straightforward design and reliability. They consist of fewer moving parts than thermostatic valves, making them less prone to malfunction and easier to maintain.

  • Cost-Effectiveness: Pressure-balance valves are generally less expensive than thermostatic valves, making them a popular choice for budget-conscious homeowners looking to add a layer of protection against temperature fluctuations.

How It Works

The mechanism of a pressure-balance valve is relatively simple:

  • Balancing Pressure: Inside the valve, a spool or piston moves in response to changes in water pressure. If the cold water pressure drops (like when a toilet flushes), the valve automatically reduces the hot water pressure to match. This balance keeps the overall water temperature in your shower stable, despite the drop in cold water pressure.

  • Immediate Response: The valve reacts instantly to changes in water pressure, ensuring that the temperature of the water remains consistent and safe for the duration of your shower.

  • Safety Feature: While the primary purpose is to maintain comfort, the safety aspect of preventing scalds or cold shocks is a significant benefit. This is particularly important in households with children or elderly individuals, where sudden temperature changes can pose a greater risk.

Thermostatic Valve vs. Pressure-Balance Valve5

Comparative Analysis: Thermostatic Valve vs. Pressure-Balance Valve

When choosing between a thermostatic valve and a pressure-balance valve for your shower system, it’s essential to understand how each function and their respective benefits and limitations. 

This comparative analysis aims to provide clear insights into both options to help you make the best decision for your needs.

Temperature Control

  • Thermostatic Valve: Offers precise temperature control. Once you set a desired temperature, the valve maintains it consistently, regardless of fluctuations in water supply temperatures or pressures. This is ideal for those who want the water to remain at a specific temperature throughout the shower.

  • Pressure-Balance Valve: Reacts to changes in water pressure to maintain a stable temperature. While effective at preventing temperature spikes, it does not allow for setting an exact temperature. Its primary function is to balance the hot and cold water pressure to prevent sudden changes in shower temperature.

Safety Features

  • Thermostatic Valve: Provides a high level of safety against scalding by directly controlling the water temperature. Most models come with a built-in safety stop at 38°C (100°F) to prevent the water from becoming too hot.

  • Pressure-Balance Valve: Also offers protection against scalding by maintaining consistent water pressure, thereby preventing sudden temperature changes. However, it does not prevent overheating due to fluctuations in the hot water supply.

Installation Process

  • Thermostatic Valve: Typically more complex and may require professional installation. The installation process might involve adjusting your plumbing system to accommodate the valve, especially in older homes.

  • Pressure-Balance Valve: Generally simpler to install and may be more compatible with existing plumbing systems. However, professional installation is still recommended to ensure optimal performance and safety.

Cost Consideration

  • Thermostatic Valve: Tends to be more expensive both in terms of the initial purchase price and installation costs. However, the investment can be worthwhile for the added convenience and safety features.

  • Pressure-Balance Valve: More budget-friendly, both for the valve itself and for installation. It offers a cost-effective solution for enhancing shower safety and comfort.

Thermostatic Valve vs. Pressure-Balance Valve4

FAQs on Thermostatic Valve vs. Pressure-Balance Valve

1. Can I install a thermostatic valve in an existing shower system?

Yes, you can install a thermostatic valve in an existing shower system, but it may require modifications to your plumbing. 

2. Will a pressure-balance valve work if my home has low water pressure?

A pressure-balance valve is designed to work under various water pressure conditions, including low pressure. 

3. Can I adjust the maximum water temperature on a thermostatic valve?

Yes, most thermostatic valves allow you to set a maximum water temperature limit. This is a safety feature to prevent scalding, and it can be particularly useful in households with children or elderly members.

4. How often do these valves need to be replaced?

Both thermostatic and pressure-balance valves are designed for durability. The lifespan can vary based on the quality of the valve, water quality, and usage patterns, but with proper maintenance, they can last many years. 

Making the Right Choice - From Temperature Control to Safety

The decision between a thermostatic and pressure-balance valve ultimately depends on your specific needs, preferences, and budget. If precise temperature control and additional safety features are priorities, and you’re willing to invest more upfront, a thermostatic valve may be the best choice. 

On the other hand, if you’re looking for a more affordable option that still significantly improves shower safety and comfort, a pressure-balance valve could be the answer.

The right choice varies from household to household, and what works best for one might not be the ideal solution for another. Consider your unique requirements and consult with a professional if you’re unsure which option will best serve your needs.

Video of Thermostatic Valve versus Pressure balance valve:

PDF version:

You may also be interested in these topics about Innovative Shower Technologies And Accessories...

Do you live in Ahwatukee, Chandler, Gilbert, Mesa, Tempe,  Sun Lakes, Laveen, or South Phoenix?

Ready to talk about your remodeling needs?

Take the next step...

About the author

Hi my name is Jeremy Maher. My wife, 2 kids and I went through Contractor Nightmares for 3 years straight.

Ben, Mark, and I teamed up to start Phoenix Home Remodeling to help homeowners remodel without the common contractor nightmares.

Learn more about Jeremy's expertise and topics he likes to write about on his author page.