The Timeless Secret: When to Refinish or Replace Your Kitchen Cabinets

When your kitchen cabinets start looking weary, that age-old question pops up: should you refinish or replace your kitchen cabinets?

You should refinish your kitchen cabinets when they show wear but have a solid structure and replace them if they're damaged, dysfunctional, or outdated in design. 

Irrespective of your choice, you should always remember employing a kicthen remodeling expert is your best bet to getting a perfect job done.

That said, let's delve into this timeless secret and find deeper answers for your culinary haven.

The Emotional And Financial Ties To Your Cabinets

  • Memories and Attachments: Think about it: How many family gatherings, late-night snacks, or impromptu dance sessions have those cabinets witnessed? Their value might just be beyond monetary.
  • Budget Considerations: Take a hard look at your budget. Refinishing is typically the more wallet-friendly option, but sometimes a replacement can be an investment in the long run.
Deciding between refinishing vs. replacing kitchen cabinets

Understanding Cabinet Refinishing

Cabinet refinishing, often seen as a middle ground between simply repainting and a full-blown replacement, has become a popular choice for many homeowners.

At its core, cabinet refinishing is about giving your existing cabinets a fresh, rejuvenated look without replacing the actual cabinet boxes.

It primarily involves removing the old finish, preparing the surface, and then applying a new stain or paint.

If you've found yourself eyeing those timeworn kitchen cabinets and considering a makeover, here's everything you need to understand about the refinishing process.

The Steps Involved In cabinet refinishing

  1. Assessment: Before you dive into refinishing, it's crucial to assess the current state of your cabinets. Check for any signs of damage or areas that might need repairs.
  2. Cleaning: Years of cooking and regular use can lead to a build-up of grease, dirt, and grime. A thorough cleaning ensures the new finish adheres well.
  3. Stripping and Sanding: This step is vital to remove the old finish and create a smooth surface. Sanding ensures that the new paint or stain adheres uniformly.
  4. Priming: Especially if you're moving from a darker to a lighter shade, a primer helps in achieving an even and vibrant color.
  5. Painting or Staining: Depending on your desired look, you can either paint or stain the cabinets. While painting offers a wide range of colors and finishes, staining can highlight the wood's natural grain.
  6. Sealing: A protective sealant or topcoat shields your cabinets from daily wear and tear, ensuring longevity.
When should you redo or swap out kitchen cabinets?

Advantages Of Cabinet Refinishing

  • Cost-Effective: Refinishing can be significantly cheaper than a full replacement or even refacing. It’s a budget-friendly way to get a new look.
  • Flexibility in Design: From bold hues to understated stains, you have a plethora of choices to achieve the desired look.
  • Environmentally Friendly: By not replacing the cabinets, you're reducing waste and making an eco-friendly choice.
  • Time-Saving: Refinishing is typically faster than replacing. You can get a brand-new look within days, not weeks.

When To Consider Refinishing

Refinishing is an excellent option when:

  • The cabinets are structurally sound and free from significant damage.
  • You're happy with your kitchen's current layout.
  • You desire a change in aesthetics without the hassle and expense of a complete remodel.

The Role of Professionals

While some homeowners opt for a DIY approach, hiring a kitchen remodel expert can ensure a smoother process and a finish that lasts.

They bring expertise, the right tools, and an understanding of materials that can make a world of difference in the outcome.

Choosing to refinish or get new kitchen cabinetry

The Journey of Cabinet Replacement

Replacing means going out with the old and in with the new! This process involves removing the old cabinets and installing brand-new ones.

Why Replacement Might Be Right For You

  • Structural Damage: Beyond any hope of repair.
  • Modern Upgrades: Want those soft-close hinges or under-cabinet lighting?
  • Complete Redesign: Dreaming of a whole new layout?
When to Refinish or Replace Your Kitchen Cabinets

Comparing Cabinet Refinishing and Replacement





     Typically Lower

 Generally Higher


A few days 

  Can take weeks


Minimal disruption

 Not usable during the process

Evaluating Long-term Value

Sure, refinishing might save you a buck today. But will you need to replace them in a few short years anyway? 

Evaluate the longevity of each option and how it fits into your future home plans.

Deciphering the time to touch up or trade kitchen cabinets

Taking the Leap: Making the Decision

It's a mix of introspection and practicality. Consider your budget, the emotional value of your cabinets, and the desired outcome. And always remember to consult with a professional!

Expert Tips for Cabinet Care

Regardless of your choice, proper care ensures longevity. Regular cleaning, avoiding excess moisture, and timely minor repairs can keep those cabinets looking spick and span!

FAQs on When to refinish or replace Your Cabinets

How often should kitchen cabinets be replaced?

On average, well-maintained kitchen cabinets can last anywhere from 20 to 50 years. Factors like usage, material, and environmental conditions can impact their lifespan.

Is it cheaper to refinish or replace Your kitchen cabinets?

Refinishing is generally more cost-effective than replacing it. If the cabinets are damaged or you desire a complete redesign, replacement might be a justified expense.

Can refinishing provide a completely new look to my cabinets?

Absolutely! With the right techniques and finishes, you can achieve a dramatically different look, from modern to rustic.

What's the most durable material for kitchen cabinets?

Hardwood species like maple, cherry, and oak tend to be durable choices. The finish and maintenance also play a significant role in their longevity.

How long does it take to refinish kitchen cabinets?

It varies based on the method and extent, but typically, it can take anywhere from a few days to a couple of weeks.

Will replacing my cabinets increase my home value?

Yes, a modern and functional kitchen can significantly boost your home's market value. But always weigh the return on investment.

On a final note

Unveiling the timeless secret isn't a one-size-fits-all answer. Whether you choose to refinish or replace, it's about making an informed decision that caters to your unique needs.

So, wear that decision-making hat, consult the kitchen remodel experts, and let your kitchen shine in all its glory!

Video of When to Refinish Or Replace Your Kitchen Cabinets

PDF version:

You may also be interested in these topics about Kitchen cabinet guide...

Do you live in Ahwatukee, Chandler, Gilbert, Mesa, Tempe,  Sun Lakes, Laveen, or South Phoenix?

Ready to talk about your remodeling needs?

Take the next step...

About the author

Hi my name is Jeremy Maher. My wife, 2 kids and I went through Contractor Nightmares for 3 years straight.

Ben, Mark, and I teamed up to start Phoenix Home Remodeling to help homeowners remodel without the common contractor nightmares.

Learn more about Jeremy's expertise and topics he likes to write about on his author page.