Bathtub Vs Soaking Tub: Discover The Key To Your Serene Sanctuary

You've been dreaming of creating the perfect serene sanctuary in your home, right? A place where you can soak away stress and revitalize your body and mind.-

The key to this zen-like space is deciding between a traditional bathtub vs soaking tub. Each has unique benefits and considerations, so let's dive into the details.

Both bathtubs and soaking tubs offer comfort and relaxation features that are sure to please but differ in size requirements, installation processes, maintenance needs, and cost implications.

So with a bathroom remodeling specialist - together, we'll explore these factors so you can make an informed decision for your tranquil oasis.

What is the difference between a regular bathtub and a soaker tub?

There's no denying the allure of a bathtub, offering a personal retreat that brings relaxation and tranquility into your home. 

Material options for bathtubs are diverse, ranging from traditional porcelain to modern acrylic or even luxurious marble. Each material adds its unique aesthetic appeal, transforming your bathroom into an oasis.

You can add a dash of drama with the glossy finish of copper or keep it minimalistic with sleek stainless steel. Not only do these bathtubs elevate your décor, but they also serve as places where you can unwind after long, tiring days.

Beyond their undeniable charm and elegance, bathtubs offer remarkable health benefits too. The warm water helps to alleviate muscle tension and promotes better sleep. 

It gives you much-needed privacy for practicing mindfulness or indulging in self-care rituals like reading a book or sipping wine without interruptions.

But remember, bathtub safety is paramount - so consider options with slip-resistant surfaces and accessible handrails if needed. Also, be aware that water usage typically depends on the size of your tub; thus, plan accordingly to conserve water while enjoying your relaxing soak.

White freestanding bathtub

What Is the Advantage of a Soaker Tub?

For a truly indulgent bath experience, you can't beat the deep, immersive relaxation a soaker tub offers. These generous bathtubs provide more depth than standard tubs, allowing for full-body immersion that maximizes therapeutic benefits. 

Imagine sinking into warm water after a long day, tension melting away as the tub's design contours to your body and encourages stress release. It's not just about comfort, though; soaker tubs offer enhanced privacy due to their deeper design.

Soaker tubs benefit your health and well-being and are highly efficient regarding water usage. They often require less water than regular bathtubs, contributing positively to water efficiency goals without compromising luxury. 

Their aesthetic appeal is another added advantage; they present an opportunity to make a stylish statement in any bathroom with their various shapes and designs - whether traditional or contemporary. 

Regarding longevity, these tubs are built to last with durable materials, such as porcelain or acrylic.

White soaking tub

What Is The Advantage Of A Soaker Tub?

Soaker tubs have gained popularity for their luxurious and relaxing bathing experience. But they come with a few drawbacks that potential buyers should consider. 

If you're considering installing a soaker tub in your bathroom, it's essential to be aware of these factors before deciding.

  • Space Requirement: Soaker tubs are generally larger and deeper than standard bathtubs. As a result, they can take up more floor space in the bathroom. This can be a drawback, especially in smaller bathrooms with limited space. 
  • Water Consumption: Due to their larger size, soaker tubs require more water than regular bathtubs. This can lead to higher water consumption, which may not be environmentally friendly or cost-effective, particularly in regions with water scarcity or where water bills are a concern.
  • Longer Filling Time: Filling a soaker tub takes more time due to its larger capacity. This can be inconvenient for those who prefer quick baths or have limited time in their daily routine.
  • Weight: Soaker tubs can be quite heavy, especially those made from materials like cast iron or stone. Installing them on upper floors or in older buildings that may not be structurally designed for such weight could pose a challenge.
  • Cost: Soaker tubs are often more expensive than standard bathtubs. The cost can vary based on the material, design, and brand, making them a less budget-friendly option for some homeowners.
  • Accessibility: The deep design of a soaker tub can make it less accessible for people with mobility issues or disabilities. Stepping into and out of the tub may be more challenging, and it might require additional safety features like grab bars to ensure a secure bathing experience.
  • Cleaning Difficulty: Cleaning a larger tub can be more time-consuming and strenuous than a smaller one. The extra space inside the tub can be harder to reach and maintain.
  • Heating Requirements: Filling a larger tub with hot water might require a more substantial amount of heating, which could impact energy consumption and utility costs.

Considering Space and Size Requirements

Space optimization is crucial when assessing if your current bathroom setup can accommodate this bathtub upgrade. Remember, a soaking tub requires more room than an average bathtub due to its depth and length. 

While these tubs provide a more immersive bathing experience, they can take up significant floor space, impacting room aesthetics and storage possibilities.

Consider the following factors to help you decide whether a soaking tub is suitable for your space:

  • Size comparison: Ensure you accurately measure your existing bathtub and the desired soaker tub. The latter will be larger, but how much larger depends on the specific model.
  • Space optimization: Think about how installing a larger tub will affect other fixtures in your bathroom – you might need to rearrange things for better flow.
  • Design implications: A bigger tub could require additional renovations or upgrades, such as new flooring or wall tiles.
  • Room aesthetics: Consider whether a large soaking tub will enhance or hinder your bathroom's overall look and feel.
  • Storage possibilities: With less floor space after installing a soaker tub, assess where you'll store towels, toiletries, and other essentials.

White walk-in bathtub

Evaluating Comfort and Relaxation Features

You're likely aware that 85% of American adults report feeling stress daily, and what better way to unwind than with comfort features tailored for relaxation in your new soak tub?

Ah, the immense relief of hydrotherapy effects as warm water massages your tired muscles. Coupled with aromatherapy benefits, you'll experience an enhanced level of tranquility as soothing scents like lavender or eucalyptus waft around your bathroom sanctuary.

Consider sound system integration into your bathing area to enhance this sensory delight further. Imagine the soothing sounds of nature or soft melodies washing over you as you recline in your tub.

Next, let's ponder on chromotherapy options - these involve using colored lights to influence mood and create a serene atmosphere. Soft blue can induce calmness, while vibrant reds may invigorate energy levels.

White bathtub with window beside it

Examining Installation and Maintenance Factors

Plumbing complexities are a real thing to consider. Bathtubs may seem straightforward, but their installation can be tricky, especially if you're dealing with freestanding models or those requiring extensive pipework.

On the other hand, soaking tubs offer simplicity in terms of fitting, as they are often designed to fit seamlessly into corners or along walls. Eco-friendliness also comes into play here; soaking tubs typically use less water than regular bathtubs, making them a more sustainable choice for the environmentally conscious.

Regarding material durability and aesthetic preferences, bathtubs and soaking tubs have their charms and challenges.

Bathtubs made from traditional materials like cast iron or steel last longer but might need to blend better with a modern bathroom design.

Soaking tubs made from acrylic or fiberglass provide flexibility in design options but may require more meticulous care to maintain their luster over time.

Your safety measures should also be scrutinized when deciding between these two options; while soaking tubs tend to be deeper – offering an immersive relaxation experience – they could pose accessibility issues for some individuals due to their depth and lack of grab bars around the edges.

White bathtub and glass shower wall

Comparing Costs and Budget Considerations

When it's time to crunch numbers, the cost difference between a traditional bathtub and a soaking tub can be quite significant. HomeAdvisor says the average cost of installing a new bathtub ranges from $1,000 to $4,500, while a soaking tub installation can set you back anywhere from $2,000 to $7,000.

Regardless of your decision, budget planning is essential as these costs don't include potential plumbing modifications or other related expenses.

Now let's delve deeper into cost variables that could impact your final bill. If you're leaning toward luxury upgrades like built-in heaters for your soaking tub or high-tech showerheads for your standard bath setup, prepare for increased costs. 

Bathtub Price

Seeking Professional Advice and Recommendations

Consulting with experts in bathroom fixtures can offer a wealth of knowledge on material selection, design options, plumbing considerations, and safety features. These professionals understand that you're not just trying to create a beautiful space but also a serene sanctuary that serves your comfort and the well-being of others in your home. 

They won't just focus on aesthetics but will also guide you through practical aspects like durability, maintenance requirements, water consumption rates for different tub types, and potential installation challenges, among other technical details.

Engaging professional help is crucial whether you are leaning towards a standard bathtub or considering an indulgent soaking tub. Remember that expert consultation isn't just about getting recommendations; it's also about having someone who understands your vision and can translate it into something tangible while ensuring functionality isn't compromised. 

To make this process simpler for you, we've compiled some key points worth discussing with your selected professional in the table below:

Expert Consultation Topic

Bathtub Considerations

Soaking Tub Considerations

Material Selection

Lightweight materials like acrylic or fiberglass are cost-effective and easy to install but may lack durability compared to cast iron or steel bathtubs.

Soaking tubs come in more luxurious materials, such as copper or stone, offering unparalleled heat retention properties but at a higher cost.

Design Options

Standard bathtubs have limited design flexibility due to their compact size, but they offer various colors and finishes.

Soaking tubs allow greater creative freedom with numerous shapes (round, oval), sizes (freestanding or built-in), and even jetted options.

Plumbing Considerations

Bathtub installation generally involves less complex plumbing work.

Installing soaking tubs may require additional plumbing modifications due to their larger size and capacity.

Safety Features

Grab bars can be installed for added security during entry/exit; non-slip mats should be used as bathtubs can get slippery when wet.

Due to their more profound nature soaking tubs might require steps for safer access; consider models with built-in seats for increased safety.

White bathtub with freestanding faucet

Medical and Mental Benefits of taking a bath

Indulging in the simple pleasure of a warm, comforting bath has been a cherished practice throughout history, and for good reason. Beyond the relaxation it provides, bathing offers various medical and mental benefits that contribute to overall well-being. 

  • Relaxation and Stress Relief: Bathing in warm water can promote relaxation and reduce stress. The warmth helps to soothe tense muscles and calms the mind, providing a relaxing environment to unwind and de-stress after a long day.
  • Improved Sleep: A warm bath before bedtime can aid in better sleep. The rise and subsequent drop in body temperature after the bath can signal the body that it's time to rest, leading to improved sleep quality.
  • Pain Relief: Soaking in a bath, especially with added Epsom salts or essential oils, may help alleviate muscle soreness, joint pain, and mild aches and pains.
  • Enhanced Circulation: Warm water immersion can improve blood circulation. It causes the blood vessels to dilate, which in turn can boost blood flow throughout the body.
  • Cleansing and Hygiene: Regular bathing helps clean the skin and removes dirt, sweat, and bacteria, reducing the risk of skin infections and other skin-related issues.
  • Respiratory Benefits: Inhaling steam during a bath can benefit the respiratory system. It may help to alleviate congestion and ease breathing, particularly for individuals with respiratory conditions like sinusitis or bronchitis.
  • Skin Care: Bathing with certain ingredients like oatmeal or chamomile can benefit sensitive or irritated skin. Bathing can moisturize the skin, keeping it soft and hydrated.
  • Mental Clarity and Focus: Taking a bath can have mental clarity and focus benefits. The time away from distractions allows one to reflect, gather thoughts, and find mental clarity.
  • Mood Enhancement: Bathing in warm water triggers the release of endorphins, which are natural mood boosters, leading to a positive and elevated mood.
  • Aromatherapy: Adding essential oils to the bathwater can provide aromatherapeutic benefits, promoting relaxation, reducing anxiety, and improving mental well-being.
  • Improved Heart Health: Some studies suggest that regular hot baths may be associated with a lower risk of heart disease, possibly due to improved circulation and reduced stress.

Making the Final Decision of a bathtub VS soaking tub

Step into the exciting journey of transforming your home into a private sanctuary with Phoenix Home Remodeling! Now's the time to seize the opportunity of making a monumental decision - choosing the perfect oasis of relaxation within your home.

Remember, your oasis should also be a wise investment. We'll assist you in striking the perfect balance, considering future resale value while incorporating your preferences. With us, you're creating an aesthetically pleasing sanctuary and increasing your home's future marketability.

Take the first step to turn your home into a haven you've always dreamed of. Partner with Phoenix Home Remodeling today - because your perfect retreat is just a call away. Reach out to us now to start this transformative journey!

FAQs: Bathtub vs Soaking Tub

What materials are typically used in the construction of bathtubs and soaking tubs?

Tub durability, cost comparison, maintenance requirements, eco-friendliness, and aesthetic appeal are all factors in your tub choice. Materials range from resilient acrylic and porcelain to luxurious copper or stone - each with unique pros and cons.

How long does it typically take to fill a soaking tub compared to a regular bathtub?

Filling time factors vary, but a soaking tub's capacity typically requires more water. Employing efficient water use and smart tub-filling techniques can expedite the process. However, it generally takes longer than filling a regular bathtub.

Can I use bath salts, oils, or bubble bath in a soaking tub?

Yes, you can use salt selections, oil types, and bubble bath brands in your soaking tub. However, proper tub maintenance and appropriate soaking accessories are essential to prevent damage.

Are there any health benefits associated with using a soaking tub?

Absolutely! Soaking tub hygiene promotes clean, healthy skin. Aquatic therapy in a soaking tub also helps reduce stress, and sensory deprivation can offer significant mental benefits.

What are some common issues or problems people face with bathtubs and soaking tubs?

Don't fret over tub maintenance or slippery surfaces. Drainage issues, installation difficulties, and tub accessibility can be daunting but are easily manageable with proper care. Your serene sanctuary is within reach with the right approach.

Video of this post:

Podcast about soaking tubs and bathtubs:

PDF version:

Do you live in Ahwatukee, Chandler, Gilbert, Mesa, Tempe,  Sun Lakes, Laveen, or South Phoenix?

Ready to talk about your remodeling needs?

Take the next step...

About the author

Hi my name is Jeremy Maher. My wife, 2 kids and I went through Contractor Nightmares for 3 years straight.

Ben, Mark, and I teamed up to start Phoenix Home Remodeling to help homeowners remodel without the common contractor nightmares.

Learn more about Jeremy's expertise and topics he likes to write about on his author page.