Alcove Bathtub Vs Drop In: Which One Provides The Most Value?

Ah, the bathtub. You think it's just a simple choice.

But even the humble tub can be a significant decision.

Alcove bathtubs and drop-in models are two popular options, yet, these two couldn't be more different if they tried.

To answer the question of which one provides more value is tricky as it depends on space, budget, and design preference; alcove tubs are typically more cost-effective and ideal for small bathroom, while drop-ins can elevate bathroom aesthetics by providing design flexibility.

In this guide, we'll take you through an honest comparison of alcove bathtub vs drop in to help you make an informed choice based on value and your needs. 

We'll compare bathroom remodel services including installation procedures, costs, and resale values while considering aesthetics and functionality.

Our goal is to empower you with knowledge so that your bathtub serves as an oasis for relaxation and adds significant value to your home improvement endeavors.

What Is the Difference Between Alcove and Drop in Tub?

It's essential to weigh the benefits of each option carefully.

An alcove bathtub between three walls can save precious space while offering easy installation and lower costs.

On the other hand, a drop-in tub provides flexibility in design and placement, often becoming the statement piece of your bathroom with its luxury aesthetic appeal.

White Alcove bathtub

What Are the Benefits of an Alcove Bathtub?

Alcove bathtubs are an excellent hit for their durability and can withstand long-term use without significant wear or tear. This makes them a smart choice if you seek longevity in your investment. 

These tubs are known for their space-saving design, making them ideal for smaller bathrooms where every inch matters. They're designed to fit snugly between three walls, maximizing your bathroom's floor area.

Another benefit of alcove bathtubs is their aesthetic appeal, which enhances the overall look of your bathroom. They come in various styles and finishes that can be tailored to match any home decor. 

When it comes to maintenance ease, they've got you covered too! These tubs have fewer components, meaning less cleaning and upkeep over time than drop-in bathtubs. 

Last but essential is comfort comparison: while some might argue that drop-ins provide better comfort due to their deeper design, many users find alcove bathtubs comfortable enough for regular bathing routines.

White alcove tub

What Are the Benefits of a Drop-In?

If you're looking for a tub that screams luxury and sophistication, a drop-in might be your cup of tea. Drop-in aesthetics are undeniably top-notch - like having your spa at home!

These bathtubs can be made from various bathtub materials, including acrylic, cast iron, marble, or even copper. This wide range of options allows you to choose something that matches your bathroom decor perfectly while meeting your specific durability needs. 

Consider the space requirements for such tubs; they typically require more room than their alcove counterparts due to their freestanding nature.

They're generally easier to clean and maintain because they don't have any attached walls or panels on three sides like alcove baths. Maintenance efforts mainly involve regular cleaning and occasionally resealing the area around the tub if it's made from a porous material like stone or concrete.

If you value style over simplicity and have enough space to spare in your bathroom layout plan, embracing the elegance of a drop-in bathtub could add significant value to your home while also enabling you to serve guests with refined taste in luxurious comfort.

drop in tub for phoenix homeowner

Can You Use an Alcove Tub as a Drop-In

Transforming your alcove tub into a drop-in might seem like repurposing an old pair of jeans into trendy cut-offs, but it's not as straightforward as snipping off the legs. It's a process that requires consideration of several factors, including space constraints and plumbing adjustments.

We do not recommend that, and it is best to buy a new bathtub. There are too many risks and mediocre modifications to try and make that work for your needs. 

Alcove tub and shower

Drop in vs Alcove Bathtubs Cost Comparison

Before diving into your bathroom remodel, it's essential to understand the cost implications of choosing between a drop-in and an alcove tub. 

The decision should be based on your budget, material selection, space requirements, maintenance ease, installation, and comfort comparison.

Cost Factors

Drop-In Bathtub

Alcove Bathtub

Material Cost

Variable, depending on selected material (acrylic, cast iron, marble, etc.). The range can go from affordable to high-end luxury.

Typically less expensive as they're usually made of fiberglass or porcelain-enameled steel.

Installation Cost

Potentially higher due to the need for a platform or frame for installation.

Generally lower because of their three-wall design, which simplifies the installation process.

Maintenance Cost

It may increase over time due to potentially more complex cleaning and repair processes.

Typically lower due to the easy access for cleaning and repairs.

Space Optimization Cost

It may incur additional costs if bathroom remodeling is needed to accommodate the tub.

It can save costs associated with space remodeling due to its efficient design for smaller spaces.

Type of Bathtub

Average Cost of Tub

Average Installation Cost


$500 - $1,500

$1,500 - $3,000


$800 - $2,000

$500 - $1,500

Note: These costs are estimates and can vary depending on several factors, such as the specific model of the bathtub, your location, the materials used, labor costs, and any additional work needed, such as plumbing or finishing.

white drop-in bathtub

Drop-In vs Alcove Bathtubs Installation Process

Ready to dive into the nitty-gritty of installing your new bathtub? 

The first thing you'll need to consider is space requirements. Alcove tubs are designed to fit snugly into a three-wall enclosure, making them ideal for smaller bathrooms or spaces where every inch counts.

On the other hand, drop-in bathtubs require a pre-built platform or frame – adding an extra layer of complexity to their installation process. However, these models have more flexibility in positioning as surrounding walls don't constrain them.

Regarding plumbing considerations and tub materials, both types pose unique challenges. With alcove tubs, existing plumbing lines may limit your choices; heavier materials like cast iron might be impractical unless floor reinforcement is possible.

Conversely, drop-ins allow for more material options but often require additional plumbing work due to their freestanding nature. And remember maintenance needs! 

Alcove designs tend to accumulate less dust and are easier to clean due to their confined space, while drop-ins may attract more dirt around their base area but provide easy access for repairs if necessary.

Whether you value ease of cleaning or repair could influence your choice here too.

Drop-In Vs Alcove Bathtubs

Resale Value and Home Improvement Considerations

Your heart might skip a beat when you realize the potential boost in your home's resale value after choosing the right bathtub for your remodeling project. The type of bathtub you choose can significantly impact your property appraisal value, so carefully consider alcove and drop-in bathtubs.

Alcove tubs are often seen as more practical due to their space-saving design, making them a popular choice for smaller homes or apartments. On the other hand, drop-in bathtubs have an undeniable luxury appeal that can elevate a bathroom's aesthetics and potentially increase your home's market price.

Consider these factors when deciding:

  • Property Appraisal Impact: A well-chosen bathtub can add value to your property. Drop-in bathtubs exude elegance and luxury, while alcove tubs offer practicality and functional benefits.

  • Bathroom Space Optimization: An alcove bathtub is ideal for working with limited space, as they fit snugly into three-wall recesses. Drop-ins require more room but can be striking centerpieces in larger bathrooms.

  • Material Durability Comparison: Both alcove and drop-in tubs come in various materials like acrylic, cast iron, or fiberglass with different durability levels - so choose wisely based on usage expectations and budget.

  • Maintenance Requirements: It's important to understand each bathtub type's maintenance needs; some might need more frequent cleaning or upkeep than others.

  • Trending Bathtub Styles: Pay attention to current trends in bathroom design; trending styles will be more appealing during property appraisals.

Bathtub Resale Value

Final Thoughts on Choosing Between Alcove Bathtub and Drop In

Confused between the practicality of an alcove tub and the luxurious appeal of a drop-in tub? Whether you lean towards a space-saving solution or a statement piece, Phoenix Home Remodeling is here to help. 

We understand the importance of a balance between functionality, design, and cost. That's why we provide comprehensive bathroom remodeling services that cater to your unique needs and preferences. 

With us, you can rest assured that you're making the right investment, whether it's an easy-to-install alcove bathtub for a compact space or a stylish drop-in tub to enhance your bathroom's aesthetics. 

FAQs: Alcove Bathtub and Drop-In Tubs

What are the cleaning and maintenance requirements for alcove and drop-in tubs?

Both alcove and drop-in tubs need regular cleaning to maintain their aesthetic appeal. Material durability affects maintenance needs. Consider price, space utilization, and comfort levels when choosing the right tub for your home.

Are there any special features available in alcove or drop-in bathtubs?

Yes, both alcove and drop-in bathtubs come with unique features. Material selection affects comfort levels and safety features. Installation costs vary, but higher water capacity often means more luxury.

How long does the installation process typically take for each type of tub?

Alcove tubs, due to plumbing modifications and materials used, may take 1-3 days with professional help. Drop-ins could be quicker or DIY feasible, depending on the design.

What are the potential drawbacks of choosing an alcove bathtub over a drop-in, and vice versa?

Choosing an alcove tub can raise installation costs due to complex plumbing requirements. It also limits space, affecting resale value. Drop-ins offer more material quality options but may only suit some bathroom layouts.

Can alcove and drop-in tubs be used with any bathroom style or layout?

Absolutely! Both alcove and drop-in tubs can work with any bathroom style. However, consider space utilization, aesthetic appeal, budget considerations, material options, and potential installation difficulties when choosing the perfect fit for your layout.

Podcast about Alcove and Drop in Bathtubs:

Video of this post:

PDF version:

Do you live in Ahwatukee, Chandler, Gilbert, Mesa, Tempe,  Sun Lakes, Laveen, or South Phoenix?

Ready to talk about your remodeling needs?

Take the next step...

About the author

Hi my name is Jeremy Maher. My wife, 2 kids and I went through Contractor Nightmares for 3 years straight.

Ben, Mark, and I teamed up to start Phoenix Home Remodeling to help homeowners remodel without the common contractor nightmares.

Learn more about Jeremy's expertise and topics he likes to write about on his author page.

Skip to content