Traditional Cabinet Hinges or Soft-Close Hinges: Which is Better?

Today's cabinet hinges exemplify the perfect marriage of tradition and innovation. But which among them should you go for?

Choosing traditional cabinet hinges or soft-close hinges depends on your preferences. 

Traditional hinges are cost-effective and offer a classic look but may slam shut. Soft-close hinges provide a quieter and gentler closing motion, preventing damage and reducing noise

With so many things to consider, let's take an indepth look at both hinges so you can make a more informed decision with the help of a kitchen remodel expert.

Classic vs. Slow-shut cabinet hinges

A Closer Look at Today's Cabinet Hinges

From the forged ironwork of blacksmiths in ancient times to the precision engineering of the 21st century, the journey of cabinet hinges has been both rich and revelatory.

The ancient Romans, Greeks, and Egyptians all had their own variations, often crafted from bronze and decorated with intricate designs.

During the 18th and 19th centuries, the butt hinge became a household name. Carved from a single piece of metal , these hinges were both sturdy and versatile, making them a staple in homes worldwide.

Today's hinges are no longer just about functionality. With advances in technology, they've become pieces of art, offering both aesthetic appeal and high-tech functionality.

Gone are the days of slamming cabinet doors. The introduction of soft-close technology ensures that doors shut smoothly and silently every single time.

Conventional vs. Gentle-close door hinges

The Process of Making a Hinge: Then and Now

These small yet significant devices have been pivotal in the development of doors, gates, cabinets, and various other movable barriers. 

Over time, the process of making hinges has undergone a considerable transformation. 

Here is how hinges were made in earlier times compared to contemporary methods.

Standard vs. Quiet-closing cabinet hardware

The Traditional Process: A Craft Handed Down Generations

1.  Raw Material Collection

  • Hinges were typically made from metals available locally. Common materials include iron, brass, or bronze.

2.  Manual Forging

  • Blacksmiths were the primary hingemakers. Using hammers and anvils, they would heat the metal till it was red-hot and malleable.

  • The heated metal would be beaten into the desired shape. Each strike showcased the blacksmith's expertise, ensuring the hinge's strength and durability.

3.  Detailed Artwork

  • Artisans would sometimes etch, emboss, or carve intricate patterns on the hinges, adding a decorative touch.

4.  Assembly and Finish

  • Individual components were then pieced together, often using rivets.

  • The finished product was usually treated to prevent rusting or tarnishing. Oil or wax might be applied for smooth movement and rust prevention.

Time-honored vs. Silent-close hinge designs

Modern Manufacturing: Precision and Automation at the Forefront

  1. Material Selection: Today, a wider variety of materials, including stainless steel, brass, zinc, and even plastic, are employed based on the hinge's intended function and location.
  2. Computer-Aided Design (CAD): Modern hinges start their life in a digital format. CAD tools allow for precise design, ensuring each hinge is uniform and meets exact specifications.
  3. Automated Machining: Machines equipped with these digital designs cut, mold, and shape the hinges. Processes like CNC machining offer unparalleled accuracy.
  4. Advanced Features: Innovations such as soft-close mechanisms or adjustable tension settings are integrated at this stage.
  5. Quality Control and Finish: Each hinge undergoes rigorous testing for durability and functionality. Advanced coatings, galvanization, or electroplating might be applied for enhanced aesthetics and longevity.
Typical vs. Cushioned-close cabinet fastenings

Traditional Cabinet Hinges vs. Soft-close Hinges

Cabinet hinges, those seemingly inconspicuous elements in our homes, play a pivotal role in the functional aspect of our doors and storage units.

Over the centuries, the design, materials, and functioning of these hinges have undergone substantial evolution. Here is a detailed comparison with the modern designs that are prevalent today.

1. Aesthetics and Design

Traditional Hinges

    • Traditional hinges, often visible on the cabinet's exterior, are usually ornate in design. They add an element of decorative detail that can serve as a focal point.

    • Made mostly of iron or brass, they come in various shapes and often have intricate patterns, reflecting the craft of the era they were created in.

    • Modern Soft-Close Hinges:

    • Modern designs lean towards minimalism. The trend now is for hinges to be concealed and to not interrupt the clean lines of cabinetry.

    • Contemporary hinges come in a variety of finishes to complement the color and design of modern cabinetry.

2. Functionality

Traditional Hinges

    • Offered basic pivot functionality.

    • Often required manual adjustments over time due to wear and tear.

    • More susceptible to rust and degradation, especially if made of iron.

    • Modern Soft-Close Hinges

    • Provide advanced functionalities such as soft-close mechanisms, which ensure the door closes gently without slamming.

    • Highly adjustable, allowing for seamless alignment of the door with the cabinet.

    • Often come with built-in rust resistance.

Old-style vs. No-slam door hinges

3. Installation and Maintenance

Traditional Hinges

    • Installation could be more labor-intensive, sometimes requiring skilled craftsmen.

    • Maintenance might involve regular oiling and occasional realignment.

    • Modern Soft-Close Hinges

    • Easier to install, with pre-drilled holes and templates available.

    • Require minimal maintenance and are designed to be long-lasting with fewer adjustments over time.

4. Durability and Longevity

Traditional Hinges

    • Handcrafted and robust, but without the benefits of modern-day protective coatings. This meant they could wear out faster or rust over time.

    • Their lifespan depended heavily on the material used and environmental factors.

    • Modern Soft-Close Hinges

    • Manufactured using precision engineering, ensuring a high degree of consistency and quality.

    • They are often treated with protective coatings, making them resistant to elements and ensuring a longer lifespan.

5. Versatility and Adaptability

Traditional Hinges

    • Predominantly designed for specific types of doors or cabinets.

    • Less adaptability to varied door weights or thicknesses.

    • Modern Soft-Close Hinges

    • Highly versatile, catering to a range of door designs, weights, and thicknesses.

    • Can be integrated into various types of cabinetry, from kitchens to bathrooms to wardrobes.

Concealed storage vs. Visible shelving

Challenges in Merging Tradition with Innovation

  • Striking the Right Balance: Maintaining the essence of tradition while incorporating modern technology can be a tightrope walk. Yet, many manufacturers have achieved this balance with aplomb.
  • Cost Implications: Handcrafted designs often come with a heftier price tag compared to mass-produced ones. This can be a significant consideration for consumers.

FAQs On Traditional Cabinet Hinges or soft-close hinges

How have cabinet hinges evolved over the years? 

The evolution has been dramatic, from hand-forged metalwork in ancient civilizations to the technologically advanced designs we see today.

Why are concealed hinges popular in modern design? 

Concealed hinges offer a sleek, clean look, aligning with the minimalist design trends of the 21st century.

What is the advantage of soft-close technology? 

Soft-close ensures cabinet doors shut smoothly and silently, preventing wear and tear and reducing noise.

How do manufacturers balance tradition with modern technology? 

It's a blend of respecting traditional artistry while harnessing the advantages of modern engineering and automation.

Are traditional hinges more expensive than modern ones? 

Not necessarily. While handcrafted hinges can be pricier, the cost varies based on the brand, material, and manufacturing process.

Can I retrofit my old cabinets with modern hinges? 

Absolutely! Many modern hinges are designed to be compatible with existing cabinetry, allowing for easy upgrades.

Closing thoughts

The world of cabinet hinges is a testament to the magic that ensues when tradition dances with innovation. 

While we cherish the artistry of yesteryear, we also embrace the advancements that modern technology brings to the table. After all, it's this blend of old and new that shapes the homes of today.

Video of Traditional Cabinet Hinges Vs Soft-Close Hinges

PDF version:

You may also be interested in these topics about kitchen cabinet guide...

Do you live in Ahwatukee, Chandler, Gilbert, Mesa, Tempe,  Sun Lakes, Laveen, or South Phoenix?

Ready to talk about your remodeling needs?

Take the next step...

About the author

Hi my name is Jeremy Maher. My wife, 2 kids and I went through Contractor Nightmares for 3 years straight.

Ben, Mark, and I teamed up to start Phoenix Home Remodeling to help homeowners remodel without the common contractor nightmares.

Learn more about Jeremy's expertise and topics he likes to write about on his author page.