Soak In Style: Exploring The Pros And Cons Of Different Types Of Bathtub Materials

You've worked hard to make your home a sanctuary, a place where you can unwind from the stresses of the day. Now, it's time to turn your attention to one particular room: the bathroom.

More importantly, that centerpiece of relaxation and restoration - the bathtub. As an investment in your personal comfort and property value, choosing the right bathroom remodel company to install the tub of your dreams is no small decision. 

It's not just about picking a design that suits your style; it's also about understanding how different materials impact functionality, longevity, and maintenance.

There are different types of bathtub materials: acrylic, cast iron, fiberglass, copper, composite... even glass or stainless steel! Each bathtub material has its unique pros and cons, which we will explore together for you to make an informed choice.

In essence, we'll assist you in ensuring every soak is done in style!

The Importance of Choosing the Right Bathtub Material

You've got to understand choosing the best type of bathtub material isn't just about aesthetics - it can significantly impact your bathing experience and even the longevity of your tub.

Bathtub material longevity is a crucial factor that you must pay attention to. Sure, some materials may look appealing initially, but if they need to be more durable to withstand years of use, you might find yourself replacing the tub sooner than expected.

Similarly, installation complexities need careful consideration as well. Some materials are easier to install than others; hence they could save you time and possibly reduce labor costs.

Bathtub material maintenance is also crucial in picking out the ideal one. Some bathtub materials demand consistent upkeep to keep them looking their best which might be challenging for those serving others with busy schedules or simply prefer low-maintenance options.

On another note, material comfort plays an integral role in determining how relaxing your baths will be – after all, a bathtub should serve as a sanctuary where you can unwind after long days of caring for others' needs.

Budget considerations come into play, too; while investing in quality products is essential, choosing something within your financial means is equally important without compromising on other critical factors such as durability and comfortability.

White bathtub and glass walk-in shower

Acrylic Tubs: Affordable and Insulated

If you're after affordability and insulation, acrylic tubs might be right up your alley. These acrylic tubs boast a wide array of color options matching any bathroom décor, making them popular for those looking to customize their space.

Acrylic longevity is also commendable; with proper care, these bathtubs can last for years without showing signs of wear or discoloration. But don't mistake acrylic for plastic, as the former has more resistance to scratching and staining than the latter.

Acrylic tubs maintenance tips include regular cleaning with non-abrasive cleaners and avoiding harsh chemicals which could damage the surface.

And while acrylic tubs are generally lightweight, installation challenges may arise due to their flexibility which requires solid support underneath. This means additional cost on top of your initial purchase price.

But despite this slight drawback, many homeowners still prefer acrylic tubs because they provide decent heat retention - a feature that's often overlooked but greatly appreciated during those long soaks at the end of a hard day serving other people.

White bathtub and a glass walk in shower

Cast Iron Tubs: Sturdy and Classic

Cast iron bathtubs are a top-notch choice for those seeking a blend of old-world charm and enduring strength.

Cast iron bathtubs aren't just about style; they're also known for their excellent heat retention, ensuring your bath stays warm for extended periods. 

When it comes to installation, be aware that a cast iron tub can be a heavyweight contender—literally! It's not uncommon for some models to weigh several hundred pounds so you might need professional help during installation.

Despite this challenge, many believe the weight a cast iron tub is worth it due to its solidness and stability once installed correctly.

Investing in a cast iron tub could be your perfect match if you value durability and love classic design aesthetics - coupled with excellent heat retention. Just remember: proper cast iron maintenance will be integral in preventing any potential rust issues.

White cast iron bathtub

Fiberglass Tubs: Lightweight and Easy to Clean

Fiberglass, or fiberglass-reinforced plastic (FRP), offers several benefits that might make it your material of choice when considering a new tub.

Its installation ease is one of its primary selling points; being relatively lightweight means it doesn't require extensive structural support on your bathroom floor. If you're eco-conscious and interested in sustainability, choosing a fiberglass bathtub can be considered green. 

With an increasing focus on sustainability practices within manufacturing industries, many now use recycled glass to produce these tubs. A few other perks to consider about fiberglass bathtubs include:

  • Color options: Unlike cast iron or steel tubs which often come in limited colors primarily due to their material nature, fiberglass bathtubs offers a broader range of color options for you to select from. This flexibility allows you to match your bathtub with your overall bathroom aesthetics.
  • Fiberglass longevity: While they may not last as long as cast iron tubs (which can last for decades), well-maintained fiberglass bathtubs can serve you for 10-20 years.
  • Surface reparability: Even though the surface of a fiberglass tub isn't as hardy as some other bathtub materials and might scratch more easily over time, the good news is that minor damages or scratches are generally easier and cheaper to repair.

So if you value an easy installation process, care about sustainability efforts, and like having variety in color choices while also understanding its limitations regarding longevity compared to other materials like cast iron - then yes! A fiberglass bathtub could be a fantastic fit for serving yourself  and your family in your home with style!

White fiberglass tub with black faucet

Copper Tubs: Luxurious and Unique

Imagine stepping into a copper tub, the cool metal reflecting your bathroom lights like a piece of art, giving an extraordinary and luxurious touch to your everyday bathing routine.

This isn't just about luxury; it's about connecting with craftsmanship as unique as each hand-hammered indentation. The copper aging process adds character to your tub over time, transforming it from a shiny penny hue to a rich, dark patina—a living testament to the baths you've enjoyed.

You're investing in a bathtub and supporting skilled artisans who've perfected their craft over generations.

While soaking in style has its allure, maintaining this beauty does require some attention. Copper maintenance tips include regular cleaning using mild soap and water and drying with a soft cloth to prevent water spots. Avoid harsh chemicals or abrasive materials that could scratch or damage the surface.

On top of its aesthetic appeal, copper offers health benefits too—it's naturally antibacterial and antiviral, making your bath relaxing and healthier too!

Copper tub and a big window

Stone Tubs: Elegant and Durable

With their elegance and durability, Stone tubs offer a unique combination of aesthetics and longevity that's hard to resist.

Stone tubs are synonymous with both style and sustainability. They're sourced from nature but can be crafted into designs that range from sleek modern minimalism to rustic charm. Plus, the stone is known for its heat retention properties—imagine sinking into a warm bath that stays warm long after you've filled it! 

But these benefits come with some trade-offs. To help you weigh your options, here's a quick comparison:


Bathtub Materials Pros 

Bathtub Materials Cons

Stone Sustainability

With proper sourcing techniques, stone can be an eco-friendly choice for your bathroom. It lasts longer than most materials and will only need replacing sometimes.

Quarrying can have environmental impacts if not done responsibly. Be sure to source from companies committed to sustainable practices.

Maintenance Techniques

Stone tubs are incredibly durable and resistant to damage. Regular cleaning with gentle products will keep them looking new for years.

On the downside, they may require resealing over time to maintain their appearance and prevent staining.

Unique Designs & Heat Retention

Thanks to the variety of stones available (like marble or granite), each bathtub has a unique look and feel while keeping your bathwater warmer longer!

The uniqueness comes with a price, though - stone tubs are more expensive than other types.

Black stone tub

Porcelain-Enameled Steel Tubs: Cost-Effective and Resistant to Stains

Looking for a tub that's easy on the wallet, resistant to stains, and holds heat fairly well? Consider porcelain-enameled steel tubs. This type is great for those who prioritize affordability without sacrificing quality.

Steel tub installation is relatively straightforward due to its lightweight nature compared to other materials like cast iron or stone. They offer impressive longevity, too – with proper care and maintenance, your enameled steel bathtub can serve you for many years.

Speaking of maintenance, you can follow some simple tips to keep your tub looking its best. Regular cleaning with non-abrasive cleaners will help prevent the buildup of soap scum and hard water deposits, which can dull the glossy finish over time. Avoid harsh chemicals or abrasive scrubbing tools, which can damage the enamel coating.

As for aesthetics, enameled steel tubs offer a classic look that suits most bathroom designs and styles. Their smooth and glossy surface enhances their heat retention properties - meaning your bathwater stays warm longer than in many other bathtubs.

Porcelain tub with gold faucet

Composite Tubs: Versatile and Low Maintenance

If you crave versatility and ease of maintenance in your bathroom sanctuary, composite tubs could be your ticket to stress-free luxury. These bathtubs are made from a blend of materials, typically resin and crushed stone, resulting in a solid product with impressive composite longevity.

The resilient nature of these tubs means they can handle everyday use without showing signs of wear or damage. With the installation ease that comes with these lightweight yet durable bathtubs, you'll have more time for what truly matters: serving those dear to your heart.

With a myriad of color options and surface textures at your disposal, composite tubs offer endless possibilities for customization. Whether you're after a sleek black centerpiece or prefer subtle earth tones that mirror nature's calming palette, there's a design out there waiting to make your bathroom uniquely yours.

And let's not forget about composite tub pricing – while initial costs may be higher than some other materials, their durability makes them an excellent investment in the long run.

White Composite Tubs

Wrapping It Up

Indulge in the ultimate bathing experience with Phoenix Home Remodeling! After exploring the pros and cons of different bathtub materials, from acrylic's affordable warmth to the charm of cast iron, the lightweight ease of fiberglass, and the luxurious uniqueness of copper, you've realized that your tub should reflect your style and needs. 

Our expert team will guide you through the options, ensuring you find the best type bathtub materials for your sanctuary. Whether you prefer the versatility of composite, the modernity of glass, or the lasting hygiene of stainless steel, we'll transform your bathroom into a haven of relaxation and style. 

So, immerse yourself in pure bliss and choose Phoenix Home Remodeling for an exquisite bathing retreat!

Master bathroom with bathtub

FAQs: Different Types Of Bathtub Materials

What common problems with bathtub materials, and how can they be resolved?

Bathtub material durability varies, potentially leading to damage. High maintenance requirements can be daunting, but repair solutions exist for most issues. Consider material aesthetics and cost comparisons before choosing your tub. 

How can one determine the best bathtub material based on their household's water type?

Hard water impact vs. material durability, an intriguing analysis awaits you! To choose the best bathtub material, consider cost-effectiveness, maintenance needs, and eco-friendliness. Understanding your household's water type guides this decision effectively.

Are there any bathtub materials that are particularly good for people with allergies or sensitivities?

When considering sensitivity issues, hypoallergenic materials like resin bathtubs are ideal. They're non-toxic, allergy-friendly, easy to clean, and have significant advantages for those with allergies or sensitivities. Make your bath time a worry-free experience!

What are some creative ideas for repurposing old bathtubs made from different materials?

Breathe new life into your old tub! Turn it into garden planters for a green oasis, pet beds for your furry friends, outdoor sofas for relaxing, retro bookshelves, or even beverage coolers for summer parties.

Can bathtub materials affect the value of a home, and how?

Yes, bathtub materials can indeed affect your home's value. Material longevity influences resale impact, while aesthetics can charm buyers. Eco-friendly options are a hit, but consider maintenance requirements to maintain appearances.

Podcast about Best bathtub materials:

PDF version:

Video of this post:

Do you live in Ahwatukee, Chandler, Gilbert, Mesa, Tempe,  Sun Lakes, Laveen, or South Phoenix?

Ready to talk about your remodeling needs?

Take the next step...

About the author

Hi my name is Jeremy Maher. My wife, 2 kids and I went through Contractor Nightmares for 3 years straight.

Ben, Mark, and I teamed up to start Phoenix Home Remodeling to help homeowners remodel without the common contractor nightmares.

Learn more about Jeremy's expertise and topics he likes to write about on his author page.